Proso millet (Panicum miliaceum L.), a drought-tolerant small millet, is valued for its adaptability and nutritional quality; however, its optimal harvest window remains uncertain. Field experiments conducted during two post-rainy seasons using cultivars TNAU 145 and TNAU 164 showed that seasonal climatic variation influenced the timing of initial seed set, which occurred at 7 days after anthesis (DAA) in year 1 (2018–19) and 17 DAA in year 2 (2019–20), marking the start of eight weekly harvests. Seed physiological maturity was reached at 35 DAA (year 1) and 38 DAA (year 2), as indicated by plateaued seed dry matter accumulation (DMA), minimal membrane leakage, peak physiological performance and a distinct brown hilum depression in de-husked seeds. Delayed harvests beyond 38 DAA (year 1) and 42 DAA (year 2) resulted in a significant decline in seed yield, though seed quality remained stable until 42 and 45 DAA, respectively. Therefore, the practical harvest window was 35–38 DAA in year 1 and 38–42 DAA in year 2. Polynomial regression analysis of seed yield and quality traits further confirmed these findings. Warmer conditions in year 1 accelerated seed maturation and hastened the harvest window, while comparatively lower warmth in year 2 slightly prolonged maturation without affecting overall quality. Harvestable maturity (38 DAA in year 1 and 42 DAA in year 2) could be visually confirmed by straw-coloured panicles and seeds showing light to deep yellow colouration, oval shape and a shiny, smooth surface with pale yellow streaks, reflecting structural and physiological stabilisation. This study provides practical insight that 35–42 DAA represents an optimum harvest window under post-rainy conditions, ensuring high-quality seed production with balanced vigour, storability and yield stability in proso millet.