Economic yield improvement is a prime objective of any crop breeding programme including chilli. An understanding of the nature of gene action underlying yield and its component traits is essential to devise effective breeding strategies. In this regard, six basic generations (P1, P2, F1, F2, BC1P1 and BC1P2) derived from two crosses (NS1 × NS2 and NS3 × NS4) involving four parents were evaluated for five productivity-related traits (average fruit weight, average fruit length, average fruit width, fruits per plant and green fruit yield per plant) during the summer season of 2025. Findings based on first-degree statistics contrasted with those derived from second-degree statistics. While the former suggested genes with dominance effects predominated over additive effects, the latter indicated the predominance of genes with additive effects in controlling the expression of these productivity traits. To avoid this discrepancy, we jointly considered both approaches, as their combined interpretation offers a more reliable understanding of the genetic architecture of quantitative traits. The integrated analysis revealed that both additive and dominance gene effects play a meaningful role in the inheritance of these traits. The predicted number of gene blocks controlling the target traits further supports the polygenic nature of these traits. Therefore, in an often cross-pollinated crop like chilli where cultivar options include both open-pollinated varieties and commercial hybrids, strategies such as intermating of extreme phenotypes followed by simple selection in early segregating generations and hybrid breeding methods would greatly enhance crop improvement.